NJIB Gift Guide: 50 Stocking Stuffers from New Jersey Makers on Etsy

November 18, 2021November 17, 2021 newjerseyisntboring

Looking for stocking stuffers? New Jersey Isn’t Boring has got you covered! I’ve found 50 different stocking stuffers/small gifts from NJ makers on Etsy. Stickers, socks, pins, coffee, tea, hats, jewelry…the list goes on. I challenge you not to buy something from the list (but please do, it supports NJ makers and local businesses).

50 Stocking Stuffers from New Jersey Makers on Etsy:

1. To start I’m using my own nepotism and promoting the NJIB shop. We have new tumblers, key chains, pins, ornaments, stickers, and more.

2. Looking for the Jersey Devil? Join the search committee and show it off with this cute sticker from GetFreshFish. Fun fact: I bought this as a t-shirt from this store.

3. If you love stickers, be sure to check out BenDouglassArtShop who makes amazing pop culture stickers. I’m a big fan of this Festivus sticker.

4. If you love pop culture items, be sure to check out The Cheerful Chalk! They have lots of fun Bravo-themed merch include this sanitizer holder of an NJ Housewife in an iconic scene.

5. If you’re looking for custom gifts be sure to check out Stamped Gold! They make personalized pencils which is a really cool gift for any age.

6. Custom pet stickers? Custom pet stickers! Enchanting Sunshine will turn your picture into a water-resistant sticker of your best friend.

7. Still looking for something personalized? Be sure to visit Arielle and Anahi’s shop! This is a cute gift for anyone who wants a trendy, personalized bracelet.

8. Another fun, personalized accessory? Personalized hair clips from NEKcreative! It’s a cute gift for all the littles in your life.

9. Need another idea for kids? Jersey Family Fun has a great NJ themed activity book!

10. Mmmm chocolate. You can order artisan chocolate from Diego’s Chocolate. These are giant chocolate rolls that come in a variety of flavors like spicy chocolate, dulce de leche, almond, sea salt and more. Vegan flavors are available too.

11. If you like chocolate with your coffee, be sure to shop Relevant Roasts. Their coffee comes in a variety of roast flavors as well as fun packaging. I will be purchasing an Egg Nog coffee with this fun Hannuakah packaging.

12. Or if they’re more into tea, be sure to check out Oh, You Tease! If you can’t make up your mind on what to purchase, they also offer a variety pack.

13. And you need tea with that honey! Check out New Ark Apiaries for honey and honey-related products like soap, candles, and self-care.

14. For the organizer in your life, Calli Banana Boutique makes labels for all your organizing needs. You’ll be able to personalize all your spices and other household supplies.

15. If you’re looking to make your own spices or start your garden, Gardinnovations makes beautiful garden stakes perfect for stocking stuffers.

16. This year we’re all about self-care, so I recommend Truly Charming Soapery which had great products for bath and body. If you’re looking for something seasonal, they have lots of great items with holiday scents.

17. Men need self-care too! Check out these lip balms for men from Skin Craft Organics made in 12 Natural Chapstick Scents like Baja chocolate, a cup of Joe, cinnamon bun, and more. Made w/ Organic Coconut Oil & Raw Beeswax.

18. JustBEEWICKED has got you covered with aromatherapy inhalers! This shop is known for their Reiki-charged “Intention-Based” Items.

19. A homemade, rainbow scrub that smells like fruit loops? Sol Over Body makes beautiful body scrubs to make your skin soft.

20. Has anyone not liked a candle as a gift? MagicArtCoStore makes beautiful candles at an affordable price.

21. If my stocking was filled with cute, homemade soap I’d be happy. sweettalkdesigns has these cute Christmas cheer soaps.

22. Teachers have had a rough year, so get them something for their days off. These cute socks from CreativeCreationsLLC make a great gift item.

23. Nurses also deserve something cute! These badge reels from Simply Crafty 10 are adorable.

24. If you’re looking for NJ-themed items, I’ve got you covered. Starting with this pin from PopsicArt. Perfect for when you’re at your job and you’re not supposed to be there that day.

25. Also a fun pin, this Asbury Lanes pin from Yard Sale Press. They have a lot of cute pins, magnets, totes etc

26. Only After Rain has adorable picture coasters! They’ve permanently fused images on Spanish ceramic tiles made right in Asbury Park.

27. On my “to buy” list is this New Jersey State Sticker Pack! The pack comes with 11 Waterproof Stickers perfect for my water bottle.

28. How cute are these wood signs? MooseOliverDesigns makes these NJ signs that will fit perfectly in your stocking.

29. Need the perfect NJ themed hat? These hats from Pork Roll and Cheese are definitely going to be popular this Winter.

30. Relive the Summer with these OCNJ Sunrise Earrings from Jcaplanart! If you love Ocean City, this store has lots of OCNJ Themed Art & Hand painted creations.

31. Another pair of earrings that I love are these NJ shaped earrings from CraftedbyChele. This store makes handmade resin in clay items like earrings, key chains, and more.

32. A beach badge magnet! amesclack makes these fun magnets as well as other fun NJ magnets, stickers, prints, and more.

33. Do you have a bride in your life whose wedding was postponed a million times? Get them this beautiful ring dish from Allure Designs and Co.

34. A funny gift for dog lovers – this hair tie gift from Because of Paws is adorable and hilarious. The store makes small thank you gifts for dog lovers, veterinarians, vet techs, groomers, dog walkers, pet sitters, dog trainers, rescue volunteers etc, and donates a portion to animal charities.

35. Another funny gift – “You Suck At Parking, Seriously” cards to hand out to horrible parkers. Truth and Art Designs sells these as a pack and you know you’ll love handing them out.

36. I had to add this air freshener from AirWheres. If you know you know…

37. For animal lovers, Bubble Dog has a lot of great items for your stocking. I have personally purchased these guinea pig stickers for my brother and his wife (who have a guinea pig named Ruth!).

38. Another adorable gift is these tiny duck magnets from Marigold Home. The shop makes meticulously handcrafted magnetic bulletin boards and unique sets of SUPER-STRONG magnets.

39. I have purchased bandanas from harproseshop for my dogs and they get compliments all the time. Your dogs have stocking stuffers too, right?

40. For all my nerds out there, these Stormtrooper Buddhas from 3DPrintsByCGray are a unique gift. They sell a variety of pop culture Buddhas featuring Star Wars, Marvel, Disney, and more.

41. Nail Decals! ShopRisasPieces has plenty of fun nail decals. I personally love these Grinch themed decals.

42. You know what fits in a stocking? Purses and accessories from Everyday By Homebody. Cute coin purses, wristlets, sunglass cases, and more.

43. As someone who is trying to keep their car clean, I love these car coasters from Ashlees Custom Cups. This store makes beautiful, glittery items like tumblers, coasters, mugs, and more.

44. Shopping for your book club? I love these “Let’s Get Lit” wine glasses from BiblioWino. Bonus: you can personalize them.

45. Marshmallows! Perfect for your hot chocolate this season, or to eat on their own, CandyWithATwist is home to the original painted marshmallow.

46. For the plant lover who cannot keep plants alive (aka me) check out these gorgeous felt flowers from dollysdoohickies. Wildflowers, daises, lilys, and more. These flowers look great in your home.

46. Additionally for flower lovers, these dried flowers from PushingDownDaisies are a personal favorite. I have purchased a custom bouquet from this store that picks, presses, and designs all their own pieces so you can have a gorgeous piece of summer all year round.

47. Calling all crystal lovers! Peace of Tia sells gems and minerals that are the opposite of a lump of coal.

48. For the lover of stationery and all things eco-friendly, check out Peaceful Stationary. They make handmade prints of their original watercolor paintings and all cards and envelopes are made from 100% recycled paper.